Simulator or buddy box: which is better for learning RC?

Last updated November 21, 2026 · By the Fly Before team

Use both, in that order. A simulator is where you get the hours: orientation, circuits and dozens of landings, with crashes that cost nothing. A buddy box is where an instructor hands you a real plane and takes it back before a mistake becomes a crash. Pilots who arrive at the field with the basics already automatic get far more out of each buddy-box session.

Fly Before is the RC flight simulator for Mac that runs real ArduPilot in one click. Plug in your radio and practice every step on your Mac before you go to the field. See what Fly Before does

The question comes up in every beginner forum, and the experienced answers rarely pick one. They differ on what each tool is for. The simulator removes the cost of a mistake; the buddy box removes the risk of a real one. Neither replaces the other.

What each one teaches

SimulatorBuddy box
Cost of a crashNone; press restartLow, the instructor recovers it; a real crash is still possible
Practice timeAny evening, any weatherClub days, calm weather, the instructor's time
RepetitionsDozens of landings per sessionOne per flight
Your real plane and radioYour radio yes; a model of a similar planeYes, both
Real wind, sun, nervesPartlyYes
Someone correcting youHints and a landing scoreA person who has seen every mistake

How a buddy box works

Two transmitters are linked, by a trainer cable or a wireless trainer link. The instructor's radio is the master and is bound to the plane. While the instructor holds the trainer switch, your sticks fly the plane; the moment it is released, control returns to the instructor. Most current radios, including EdgeTX ones, have a trainer function. Many clubs offer this kind of instruction; in the US, the Academy of Model Aeronautics lists chartered clubs and its Introductory Pilot Program lets newcomers fly with an instructor before joining.

A plan that uses both

  1. Simulator first. Orientation, gentle turns and circuits until the plane flying toward you no longer causes a panic. Our ten-hour plan sets the order.
  2. First buddy-box flights. The instructor takes off and lands; you fly the circuits. Note what went wrong.
  3. Back to the simulator for exactly those moments, with the same radio. Use rewind to fly the mistake again and again.
  4. Approaches and landings on the buddy box, once you land well on the sim with help off; see landing practice.
  5. Solo when the instructor says so, then keep using the simulator for wind, failures and new planes.
A high-wing bush trainer in a banked turn over a meadow in evening light in Fly Before
The Bush trainer over the meadow: circuits at home, the hard parts with an instructor

No instructor nearby

Then the simulator carries more of the load. Pick a slow, forgiving trainer, practice until you pass the six-skill test with help off, fly your first flights on a calm day over soft grass, and ask an experienced pilot to check the plane before the maiden, even if they cannot teach. The maiden flight checklist covers the checks.

Plainly: Fly Before has no instructor mode and does not replace one. It is the practice half of the plan: your own radio, lessons with one goal each, failure drills and a five-second rewind.

Questions

What is a buddy box?

Two transmitters linked by a trainer cable or a wireless trainer link. The instructor's radio is the master: while the instructor holds the trainer switch, the student flies; let go, and control returns to the instructor at once.

Can I learn to fly RC without a buddy box?

Many pilots have, usually with a lot of simulator time and a forgiving trainer, but expect more crashes. If a club or instructor is within reach, a few buddy-box flights after the simulator are the cheapest insurance you can buy.

Do I need a simulator if my club has an instructor?

It makes the instructor's time go further. Practice the circuit, orientation and landings at home, and each field session can start at the hard part instead of the basics.

Fly Before: RC Flight Simulator is a native macOS app (Apple Silicon) for flying RC planes and fixed-wing VTOLs that runs real ArduPilot in one click through the free ArduPilot Helper. One-time purchase, not on sale yet.

Sources

Changelog

Fly it before you fly it

Native on Apple Silicon Macs. Real ArduPilot in one click. Your own radio or a PS5 controller: the setup wizard learns any USB controller in four stick moves.

Watch it fly

$49.99 once, everything included · On sale soonRequirements