Why is my EdgeTX radio missing axes or acting strange on a Mac?
Almost every EdgeTX-on-Mac problem has one of six causes: a charge-only cable, the wrong USB mode, "Sim" axis types in Advanced mode, an untouched throttle that reads as half, a channel-order or reverse setting in the model, or the joystick layout change in EdgeTX 2.11.0–2.12.2. The table below maps each symptom to its cause and fix.
Fly Before is the RC flight simulator for Mac that runs real ArduPilot in one click. Plug in your radio and practice every step on your Mac before you go to the field. See what Fly Before does
EdgeTX radios (RadioMaster, Jumper, BetaFPV, iFlight, FlySky and others) all use the same USB joystick code, so these fixes apply to all of them, in any simulator that reads standard joysticks. Where Fly Before handles something for you, we say so.
Symptom, cause, fix
| Symptom | Cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Radio not detected at all | Charge-only cable; USB mode set to storage, serial or "ask" | Use a data cable; choose USB Joystick (HID) when you plug in |
| One or two axes missing | Advanced mode with "Sim Aileron" or "Sim Elevator" axis types, which macOS ignores | Use Classic mode, or plain X, Y, Z, Rx, Ry, Rz types |
| Throttle at half until you move it | macOS reports nothing for an axis until it moves; it reads as zero (mid-range) | Move the throttle once after plugging in |
| Sticks swapped (aileron moves rudder) | Channel order in the radio differs from what the sim expects; or a mix in the model | Plain sim model memory; remap in the simulator |
| A stick works backwards | Channel reversed in the model memory | Remove the reverse, or reverse the axis in the simulator |
| Axes moved after a firmware update | EdgeTX 2.11.0–2.12.2 changed the Classic descriptor | Update to 2.12.3 or later |
| Calibration forgotten after an update | The firmware version is part of the device identifier games see | Recalibrate, or use a simulator that ignores the version (Fly Before does) |
| Switch on CH9+ only works as on/off | Classic mode sends CH9–32 as buttons | Move it to a channel between 1 and 8 |
| Extra axes missing on a big setup | Some engines read only 10 axes per device | Keep important functions on the first 8 channels |
The causes in more detail
Cable and USB mode
When you connect an EdgeTX radio, it asks what the USB port should do. Only USB Joystick (HID) makes it a game controller. If nothing appears on the Mac, rule out the cable first: many USB-C cables only carry power.
Advanced mode and the "Sim" axis types
In Advanced mode you pick a HID usage for each channel. The "Sim Aileron" and "Sim Elevator" usages belong to the HID simulation page. On macOS, SDL's joystick driver only reads Rudder, Throttle, Accelerator and Brake from that page and skips the rest, so those channels vanish. macOS also sorts axes by usage type rather than by their position, so the order you see may differ from the order you set. Classic mode avoids all of this. Radios with less than 1 MB of flash, such as the Pocket and TX12 MK2, have no Advanced mode at all.
The half-throttle start
SDL does not report an axis until it first changes, and the Godot engine reads such an axis as zero, which is the center of the range. A throttle parked at the bottom looks like half throttle. A fix was proposed in Godot and closed without merging. Fly Before treats an axis that has never moved as unknown, keeps throttle at zero and asks you to move it once.
Channel order and reversing
EdgeTX defaults to AETR. If your radio or model uses a different order, or mixes channels (elevons, V-tail, flaperons), the simulator sees something other than raw sticks. Build a dedicated sim model with four straight channels at 100% and let the simulator do any mixing.
Firmware updates
EdgeTX 2.11.0 changed the Classic joystick descriptor. Some consoles broke, and 2.12.3 restored the old layout. Separately, EdgeTX writes its version into the field that becomes part of SDL's device identifier, so the identifier changes with every update and simulators that key calibration on it forget your settings. Fly Before keys settings on USB ID and name without the version.
Channels 9 to 32 and the 10-axis limit
Classic mode gives you 8 axes (CH1–8) and turns CH9–32 into 24 buttons, pressed when the channel is above zero. Separately, Godot reads at most 10 axes and 128 buttons per device. An EdgeTX radio sends 8 axes, so that limit only matters for large HOTAS setups.
A quick test routine
- Plug in, choose USB Joystick (HID), select your plain sim model.
- Open your simulator's controller test screen (in Fly Before: Settings, Connections, Test).
- Move the throttle bottom to top once.
- Right stick right: one bar moves positive. Right stick forward: elevator. Throttle up. Left stick right: rudder.
- Flip each switch you use and check it moves a bar or lights a button.
- If anything is wrong, fix it in this order: cable and mode, model memory, Classic mode, then remap in the simulator.
How we know: the causes above come from EdgeTX, SDL and Godot source code and issue trackers, linked below. Fly Before's EdgeTX profile carries the badge "Checked against the docs". Tried on real hardware, on a MacBook Air M4: RadioMaster TX15 and PS5 DualSense.
Questions
Why does my throttle read half when the stick is at the bottom?
On macOS an axis reports nothing until it first moves, and the game libraries most Mac games use read an unreported axis as zero, which is the middle of the range. Move the throttle once after plugging in. Fly Before keeps throttle at zero until it sees the throttle move.
Why are channels 9 and up not showing as axes?
In Classic mode EdgeTX sends channels 1 to 8 as axes and channels 9 to 32 as buttons that read as pressed when the channel is above zero. Put anything you need as a smooth axis on channels 1 to 8.
Fly Before: RC Flight Simulator is a native macOS app (Apple Silicon) for flying RC planes and fixed-wing VTOLs that runs real ArduPilot in one click through the free ArduPilot Helper. One-time purchase, not on sale yet.
Sources
- EdgeTX joystick code: usb_joystick.cpp; USB descriptor: usbd_desc.c
- EdgeTX manual: Configure advanced joystick with EdgeTX
- Descriptor change and restore: EdgeTX #6320, EdgeTX #7532; Advanced mode on small-flash radios: EdgeTX #5443
- macOS joystick driver: SDL_iokitjoystick.c
- Untouched axis reads zero: Godot #105676
- SDL3 joystick driver in Godot: Godot #106218
Changelog
- : First published.