URL: https://flybefore.com/guides/realflight-vs-ardupilot-sitl/
Last updated: 2026-11-22

# RealFlight or ArduPilot SITL: which one do you need?

Last updated November 22, 2026 · By the [Fly Before team](https://flybefore.com/about/)

They do different jobs. RealFlight is a flight simulator: it models the airplane and the world and lets you fly with your sticks. ArduPilot SITL is the real autopilot code running on your computer: it decides what the servos do, but it needs a physics model to fly anything. To rehearse an ArduPilot plane, you want both halves together.
Fly Before is the RC flight simulator for Mac that runs real ArduPilot in one click. Plug in your radio and practice every step on your Mac before you go to the field. [See what Fly Before does](https://flybefore.com/) 

The question shows up whenever someone with a flight controller in their plane goes looking for a simulator. "Should I buy RealFlight, or just use SITL?" The honest answer is that SITL without a good physics model is a test harness, and a flight simulator without the autopilot cannot show you what your failsafe or mission will do. Here is how the pieces fit.

## Two halves of one rehearsal

| | A flight simulator (RealFlight, Fly Before and others) | ArduPilot SITL | 

| What it is | A physics model of the aircraft and its surroundings, plus graphics and controls | The ArduPilot firmware compiled to run on a PC instead of a flight controller | 

| What it decides | How the plane moves given control surface positions, motor power and wind | What the autopilot does: stabilisation, modes, missions, failsafes | 

| Flies on its own? | Yes, with your sticks | No, it needs a physics backend | 

| Good for | Stick skills, orientation, landings, wind | Parameters, missions, failsafe logic, ground-station practice | 

| Cost | Varies by product | Free, open source (GPLv3) | 

## How they connect

SITL reads simulated sensors (IMU, GPS, airspeed, barometer) from a physics backend and sends servo and motor outputs back. ArduPilot supports several backends:

- Built-in models. Simple aircraft models inside SITL itself. Fine for testing logic; there is no real aircraft you would recognize. 

- RealFlight. ArduPilot's documentation describes linking SITL to RealFlight 8 and 9, which run on Windows. 

- Gazebo. A robotics simulator, common on Linux. 

- X-Plane. ArduPilot documents X-Plane 10 and 11; X-Plane runs natively on a Mac, but SITL still has to be built there. 

- JSON interface. A generic protocol any simulator can implement: SITL sends servo outputs over UDP and receives the aircraft state back. Fly Before uses this route. 

## Which setup fits you

- No flight controller, learning to fly: a flight simulator alone. SITL adds nothing yet. 

- ArduPilot plane, Windows PC: RealFlight plus SITL is a documented, well-trodden route (RealFlight Evolution is $99.99 on Steam). 

- ArduPilot plane, Mac: use a Mac simulator that ships SITL, such as Fly Before, so there is nothing to build. The alternatives are building SITL yourself and pairing it with X-Plane or another backend, or running RealFlight on a separate Windows PC. See [ArduPilot SITL on Mac](https://flybefore.com/guides/ardupilot-sitl-on-mac/). 

- Developer testing code changes: SITL with the built-in models or Gazebo; graphics matter less than automation. 

## Where Fly Before fits

Fly Before is a flight simulator that ships ArduPlane 4.7 SITL as a separate free helper and connects them over the JSON interface. You fly your own power system from the [Workshop](https://flybefore.com/workshop/), turn on ArduPilot with one switch, and connect QGroundControl. FBWA, RTL, AUTO missions, radio failsafe and QuadPlane transition pass our automated test runs. [See how ArduPilot works in Fly Before](https://flybefore.com/ardupilot/) or [watch it fly](https://flybefore.com/gallery/#videos).

What it does not replace: RealFlight's large aircraft library, helicopters and multiplayer, or a Gazebo setup for robotics development.

A limit that applies to every simulator: the physics model only approximates your airframe. Use SITL rehearsals for modes, missions and failsafe behavior. Final PID tuning belongs on the real plane; Fly Before's model estimates inertia, so its gains are not your plane's gains.

## Questions

**Is ArduPilot SITL a flight simulator?**
Not on its own. SITL is the ArduPilot autopilot code running on a computer. It needs a physics model, either ArduPilot's built-in simple models or an external simulator, to tell it how the aircraft moves.

**Can I use RealFlight with ArduPilot on a Mac?**
Not directly. ArduPilot documents the RealFlight link for RealFlight 8 and 9, which run on Windows. Mac users either run RealFlight on a separate Windows PC or use a physics backend that runs on macOS.

Fly Before: RC Flight Simulator is a native macOS app (Apple Silicon) for flying RC planes and fixed-wing VTOLs that runs real ArduPilot in one click through the free ArduPilot Helper. One-time purchase, not on sale yet.

On a Mac, Fly Before gives you both halves: its own physics plus the real ArduPlane SITL.
[Watch it fly](https://flybefore.com/gallery/#videos) $49.99 once, everything included · On sale soon · [Requirements](https://flybefore.com/pricing/#requirements)

[See what Fly Before does](https://flybefore.com/)

## Related

- [Does RealFlight work on Mac?](https://flybefore.com/guides/does-realflight-work-on-mac/) 

- [ArduPilot SITL on Mac (Apple Silicon)](https://flybefore.com/guides/ardupilot-sitl-on-mac/) 

- [QuadPlane simulation without hardware](https://flybefore.com/guides/quadplane-simulation-without-hardware/) 

- [Glossary: SITL](https://flybefore.com/glossary/#sitl) 

## Sources

- ArduPilot: [SITL simulator](https://ardupilot.org/dev/docs/sitl-simulator-software-in-the-loop.html), [Using SITL with RealFlight](https://ardupilot.org/dev/docs/sitl-with-realflight.html), [Using SITL with Gazebo](https://ardupilot.org/dev/docs/sitl-with-gazebo.html), [Using SITL with X-Plane](https://ardupilot.org/dev/docs/sitl-with-xplane.html) 

- JSON backend: [libraries/SITL/examples/JSON](https://github.com/ArduPilot/ardupilot/tree/master/libraries/SITL/examples/JSON) 

- RealFlight Evolution on Steam: [store.steampowered.com/app/2069310](https://store.steampowered.com/app/2069310/) 

## Changelog

- 2026-11-15 : First published. 
- 2026-11-22 : Mac route now leads with a simulator that ships SITL; RealFlight price added.
